The Argument Against: Debbie
He asserts the ceramic dish we use for salt is unsanitary, but I believe it gives us an air of being cultured.
My partner Gene has been pestering me for ages, seeking assistance choosing salt and pepper shakers. However, I consider them to be unnecessary accessories.
Salt and pepper are already provided in plastic shakers from the supermarket, and we also have pink Himalayan salt in a small ceramic bowl from Spain, which we dispense using a wooden spoon. I like using the bowl, but Gene does not because we often end up using our fingers to distribute the salt, which he claims is unhygienic. However, only we in our home, so what does it matter?
Gene argues it would be “more hygienic and convenient” if we avoided keeping the salt in an exposed dish. However, I don’t believe shakers will add to our life in any way. Those plastic supermarket shakers work perfectly well, and I do not believe we should have additional items cluttering the countertop or crowding our small wooden table.
Another concern Gene has is about appearance and ease of use. When we have company over, he says it’s “unrefined” to have them placing their hands into the bowl, which they occasionally do. On one occasion our friend took the salt with her fingers, and Gene didn’t say anything until after she left, but he was really bothered. And he thinks supermarket shakers appear cheap.
He also wanted to decant all our cleaning liquids and washing-up liquid into simple containers. I simply fail to understand the purpose in such an action, while Gene is focused on visual appeal. We have lived together for half a decade and he’s consistently been like this. In his view, it’s better for the environment to decant things rather than buying new plastic containers all the time, but I do not believe it has a significant impact as we likely just buy salt and pepper twice a year.
Instead of shakers, I think it’s more interesting to have a little bowl of salt from Spain, because it gives the impression we are cultured and experienced travelers. Gene has spent hours searching the web and evaluating little silver antique shakers to wooden ones. It requires excessive work. Humanity got by without shakers for ages.
The Argument For: Gene
Proper shakers are more functional and elevate the table, demonstrating it was laid with care and intention
Salt and pepper shakers are often dismissed as ornamental or superfluous, but they serve a practical purpose. The primary advantage is cleanliness.
Uncovered dishes of salt, no matter how charming or artisanal they look, invite people to insert hands in or fumble with spoons. Whenever visitors do this, I shudder at the thought of all the bacteria in there. A dispenser, conversely, maintains seasonings covered and dispensed hygienically.
There’s also the issue of presentation. When guests, small touches matter. A pair of well-chosen shakers elevates the table, while plastic or glass supermarket containers look makeshift and out of place. Debbie believes it’s funny, but I like to decant everything for visual harmony. People might not remark on these little details, but presentation helps create an atmosphere, and small touches matter. A dining setup laid with deliberation feels different from one cobbled together with random containers originally held from the shop.
Ease is another factor. Shakers are engineered for speed and uniformity. A brief shake gives just the right amount without fumbling or estimating. I’ve ruined many dishes by over-sprinkling salt. Shakers would take up the identical area that the supermarket containers occupy, but they’d help us ration the salt in our meals – and they are more attractive.
I desire timber models to match our worktops and our eating surface. She is largely indifferent, but she once expressed an preference in some antique Victorian silver ones, which I’m considering. Nonetheless, I’d like to see her show more interest in our purchase, as she will be employing them too. I don’t understand the resistance.
Proper shakers integrate hygiene, functionality, and appearance in a manner that open bowls and disposable plastic containers can’t. A minor adjustment, perhaps, but one that has an impact in the feel of a shared home. Debbie should be appreciative she has a man who is so attentive about the little things.
The Panel of Opinion Givers
It appears like the opposing side will be relatively unaffected by this acquisition, while it will make Gene a lot happier. Considering the times we live in, it feels nice to have a reason to introduce a bit more beauty to the world – or simply the table.
A Commenter, 31
Gene may be correct about the look of the dining setup, but he truly ought to get over himself: the idea of transferring all liquids strikes me as extremely superfluous and a dispenser won’t stop you over-salting a dish. Salt is a germ inhibitor regardless, so the chances of contracting an illness from sharing a small bowl must be tiny.
Bob, 72
The opposition should relinquish the salt bowl in favour of some stylish fresh dispensers. His wish to optimise their home might seem a little excessive, but there isn’t anything wrong with it as provided he doesn’t impose the chore of decanting on Debbie.
A Respondent, 26
It is pleasant to have visually attractive objects in your home, and the advocate seems to genuinely care about ensuring the place appear nice for them both. Transferring the dish soap could be a bit much, but if he wants to devote his efforts doing that, to each their own.
Another Opinion, 41
Should cleanliness be the concern, clean your hands prior to handling the salt. Aesthetics is a personal preference but pepper from a mill tastes better than pre-packaged and you can measure salt better by the pinch than from a shaker.
A Final View, 30
Your Turn Be the Judge
Through our digital survey, tell us who you think should lay the table
The voting ends on Midweek October 8
Previous Results
We asked whether an individual should pay for a cleaning bill at a rental property.
99% of voters responded yes – the person is guilty
A tiny fraction of participants said no – they is not guilty
